33. Therapy

by Susan Tiner on March 24, 2011

Fallen Angel - Alexandre Cabanel

Doesn’t this dark angel seem worthy of a Wendy Brandes custom jewelry design?

Over the years people have asked how I managed to get through the challenging circumstances of my upbringing.

The answer is complicated. As a lover of bullet lists, I want to make a bullet list, but I don’t want to get ahead of myself. So I’ll try to tackle one bullet point per post over the next several posts.

The first bullet point is therapy.

Therapy is a particularly loaded topic for me since my parents used it as a way of gauging my progress against their agenda, which mainly consisted of avoiding parental responsibility.

Like Sally Draper, I was sent to therapy to be “fixed” but at some level understood that I wasn’t the problem. I can still recall sitting with various therapists, legs askew, hands fidgeting while professional eyes searched my eyes, looking for clues. What is wrong with Susan?

Meanwhile I continued working pretty hard as a young cellist and pianist and public school student, keeping an A- or B+ grade point average.

My crimes, for which I was kiddie incarcerated, had to do with staying with friends over weekends to avoid being home with my angry mother, and cavorting with boys, sometimes getting a neck hickey. Okay, there was also drinking, cigarette and dope smoking, and other similar risky behaviors, in which all of my Long Island, New York friends circa 1971 were similarly engaged.

The parents of my friends were appalled by what happened to me.

Therapy continued while I was locked up in the Suffolk County Children’s Shelter and later after I was released, the focus of it being on my behavior, not the behavior of my parents. It wasn’t difficult to put two-and-two together regarding who was paying the therapy bills and the therapy content delivered. I still remember one therapist remarking that yes, it’s difficult when parents choose not to parent, as if I should know that this is a typical situation a young person needs to accept.

I tuned out.

For solace, I turned to the life of the mind, and ultimately, after an unfortunate first marriage, embraced career and motherhood during my second marriage as a primary focus.

The Third Temptation, William Blake, 1777-1827. Love the deco-looking Jesus and the typically muscular fallen angel.

Note: doesn’t the above deco Jesus remind you of the Columbia pictures gal? (Jesus and Fashion — there’s a topic!)

I tried therapy on my own during college and my twenties and thirties, but kept encountering sad-sack practitioners, from a psychologist who scribbled on a pad and stared at me yet never spoke — well maybe once during the session he’d say something like “you seem angry” — to an LMFC who talked about herself incessantly while knitting then one day crawled under her desk to avoid a process server who interrupted our session to serve her divorce related papers, to another LMFC who routinely fell asleep during sessions.

The church seemed like a better bet, though I’m not a believer in any traditional sense. It helps considerably that the American Episcopal church is widely inclusive.

There was one brief period during my thirties, when I felt particularly vulnerable, of flirting with devoutness, but generally I self-identify as a secular humanist with great admiration for the aesthetic cultural heritage of the church and its highly-developed vision of the purpose of human life, which besides being a good person, involves understanding a) life is unfair, b) there will be death and destruction, c) carpe diem!

I also embrace ecumenism — there is much to learn from other faith traditions.

Martin and I, both avid fans of Joseph Campbell, relate to pre-Christian ideas of the plant god that we figure Christianity is layered on top of (so California!) — so technically we’re pagans or heathens, but whatever, no one is carding us at the door.

I let the seasonal liturgy wash over me, giving me thoughts to contemplate as I day dream during bible readings and sermons.

For example, this is the season of Lent, during which we’re reminded of the temptation of Christ by Satan, the fallen angel pictured in the two paintings above, and of the idea of victory over sin and death. (Every year some of my church women friends can’t help noticing that in paintings of the Temptation the fallen angel is way sexier than the figure of Christ.)

There have been many notions of victory in the history of the church, most of them focused on the afterlife in which Christ is the sovereign along with his pal God.

When we visited the Melk Abbey In Austria in December, we were both stunned by the amazing crown of victory on the high alter. Martin’s first thought was that any religious/political structure that could convince the people to devote their labor to gilding this church so elaborately could convince those same people to do literally anything.

Melk Abbey - Crown of Victory - Courtesy of http://dhgorman.com/

I am slower to make those kind of judgments, but given what happened in Austria in 1939, it does make me wonder. Maybe I’ll have a better sense of things after I finish reading The Austrians: A Thousand-Year Odyssey.

My notion of victory, in the pagan/heathen context, has to with the cycle of life and death. For me, Winter is the time of death, Spring the time of rebirth.

Flowers! - looking good despite the rain deluge

As for life beyond our earthly life-and-death cycle? The Kingdom of God?

Think of Handel. Trumpets blowing. Large bouquets of lilies. Sipping Champagne.

 

Cherry blossoms!

Happy Spring! I wish you gorgeous flowers and romantic angels.

Note: There wasn’t sufficient interest in the Chanel book giveaway so it’s hereby canceled.

Update: Martin told me that by identifying as a secular humanist I’m essentially saying I’m atheist, but that’s not true. I believe in some kind of divine reality yet remain in full possession of my intellect in interpreting its nature.

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • PDF
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Tipd
  • Twitter

{ 29 comments… read them below or add one }

1 WendyB March 24, 2011 at 11:08 am

You have a fascinating perspective on life. Can I steal this and put it on my business card? “I self-identify as a secular humanist with great admiration for the aesthetic cultural heritage of the church and its highly-developed vision of the purpose of human life, which besides being a good person, involves understanding a) life is unfair, b) there will be death and destruction, c) carpe diem!” — LOVE.

Also, Jesus = Columbia Pictures gal nearly made me laugh a jelly bean out my nose. YES, I was eating jelly beans. My nose is not magic.

Reply

2 Susan Tiner March 24, 2011 at 11:12 am

I’m really starting to wonder about your nose. I know you keep saying it isn’t magic, but you laugh so many interesting things out of it!

You can steal anything of mine you like — what’s mine is yours :-)

Reply

3 deja pseu March 24, 2011 at 12:52 pm

Not to derail this serious topic into silliness, but did you know that (a younger) Annette Benning was the model for the current Columbia Pictures lady?

Susan, it sucks that you didn’t have better parents. You sure deserved them.

Reply

4 deja pseu March 24, 2011 at 12:52 pm

Deserved better parents, I mean. ;-)

Reply

5 Susan Tiner March 24, 2011 at 1:00 pm

Pseu, “You sure deserved them” made me laugh one of Wendy’s gummy bears out of my nose!

I had no idea that Annette Benning was the model. It figures though, she is so GORGEOUS and regal.

Reply

6 The Storialist March 24, 2011 at 3:37 pm

I loved this post, Susan. So many interweaving threads.

Reply

7 Susan Tiner March 24, 2011 at 3:39 pm

Thank you Hannah. I loved your post today too.

Reply

8 K-Line March 24, 2011 at 6:50 pm

Susan: You did deserve better parents. Just goes to show that we can’t wreck our kids – because yours did not do well by you but you are nonetheless fantastic!

Reply

9 Susan Tiner March 24, 2011 at 6:56 pm

Kristin, you’re a doll. It’s true that being a good person has only partly got to do with good parents.

Reply

10 Angie Muresan March 25, 2011 at 6:49 pm

Susan, you are such a kind and compassionate woman, I find it hard to believe your mother was so unloving. You have certainly risen above all the nastiness she showed you.

By the way, I am so with your husband on that observation.

Reply

11 Susan Tiner March 25, 2011 at 7:58 pm

Thank you Angie. She doesn’t want me to write about her in public, so I can’t say much, but she actually had a compelling reason for not bonding with me. At least it made sense to me when she explained. But I hoped something more would develop from this conversation than her request, after I wrote about it, to remove the post.

Martin, not my husband actually but my unmarried life partner, will be very happy to know that you agree. I’m just now starting to understand the tragic situation in Eastern Europe as WWII unfolded. I want to learn more about Romania.

Reply

12 Angie Muresan April 4, 2011 at 9:21 pm

I may have missed something obvious, but do you have any connections with Romania, Susan?

Reply

13 Susan Tiner April 4, 2011 at 10:48 pm

Angie, I don’t have Romanian connections, personally, but want to learn more about Romania and its history.

14 Terri March 25, 2011 at 7:24 pm

This story portrays that life is a spiritual journey. When you come from such a disordered background, it is easy to understand why you would grow to appreciate a liturgy. I too like the quote that Wendy honed in on.

Reply

15 Susan Tiner March 25, 2011 at 8:07 pm

Thank you Terri. It’s sometimes difficult to defend the church affiliation among secular-liberal friends. I treasure it, and am glad to be accepted there as I am.

Reply

16 RoseAG March 26, 2011 at 1:37 pm

Been there and done that with unruly children and therapy!

Reply

17 Susan Tiner March 26, 2011 at 2:38 pm

Yes, I guess you could say I was an unruly child, but it’s not as if my parents were stepping up to the plate in terms of their own responsibilities.

Reply

18 RoseAG March 26, 2011 at 2:59 pm

Did they go too?

Reply

19 Susan Tiner March 26, 2011 at 3:33 pm

Generally not. After a couple initial consultations with Mom present I was thereafter dropped off for one on one.

20 Lisa March 26, 2011 at 4:33 pm

This is wonderful, how it is woven together. It’s as though you feel beauty, not in the cognitive realm, but elsewhere. Just graspable, just a bit.

Reply

21 Susan Tiner March 27, 2011 at 8:54 am

Yes, beauty is mostly not in the cognitive realm, though there is some beauty there as well :-).

Reply

22 savvysavingbytes March 31, 2011 at 8:57 am

I think you have something to thank your parents for. The genes that gave you your very active curiosity and inner life which have helped you through your difficult early years.

Your writing about Satan reminded me of a painting I did and gave to my parents. It was a still life with a vase of flowers and a Japanese piece of art depicting what looked to me like a very graphic dramatic head of a lion and what my mother read as the devil. I didn’t find out till years later that it really disturbed her having the devil hanging in her house.

Reply

23 Susan Tiner March 31, 2011 at 10:06 am

Hi Pat, yes, that’s a nice thought, being thankful for my genes :-).

Your story of the “devil” painting disturbing your mother reminded me of the African masks my mother had. They were really scary. I had to concentrate very hard to put them out of mind when trying to fall asleep. I seem to remember them hanging in my bedroom, which sounds super creepy, but maybe they were hanging elsewhere. Anyway, later my Mom hung them in the guest bedroom where my kids slept when we visited and so two more childhoods were disturbed by these same masks!

Reply

24 Mardel April 3, 2011 at 3:11 pm

I agree with Wendy about the quote and business card, as well as the Columbia pictures lady, except instead of jelly beans it was bourbon. Oh dear.

You so deserved better parents, and I am so happy to have found your blog. On the other hand, had you had better parents everything would be different. Thank you for surviving and evolving so eloquently.

Reply

25 Susan Tiner April 3, 2011 at 5:00 pm

Bourbon! That’s really funny. Thinking of Jesus in a goofy way is always good for a laugh. The church needs more humor, IMHO.

I try to remind myself that many of the very unique experiences I’ve had in life would not have been possible with a different background. It’s good to remember that. Thank you for the lovely compliment.

Reply

26 Mardel April 3, 2011 at 7:04 pm

Oh don’t get me started. I think religion is fabulously interesting although I can’t count myself as a believer. But as to thinking of Jesus in goofy ways, “somebody stole his body” was one of my favorite songs growing up. I grew up in the bible belt, and any outlet for mockery was welcome. At least I hope that explains it. And I wish I knew the words to a song my mother used to sing, but all I remember is “jesus playing quarterback and moses playing guard” and the refrain, which was something like “rock ‘em sock ‘em, Moses block ‘em”.

I don’t know, but sometimes I think there is something about the south….

Reply

27 Susan Tiner April 4, 2011 at 9:50 am

Ha! Along those lines, I bet you’d like Drop Kick Me Jesus Through the Goal Posts of Life.

I did a little googling and found this link with these lyrics:

There’s a football game in Heaven,
In Heaven’s own backyard
Where Jesus is the quarterback
And Moses playing guard
The angels in the bandstand,
They all let out a yell
When Jesus the quarterback
Beats the boys from Hell

Stay with God, Stay with God
Rock ‘em sock em block ‘em Jesus
Stay with God.

(Jesus on the five yard line Really doin’ God-dam fine Rock ‘em sock ‘em block ‘em Jesus, Stay with God.)

Do you remember what tune your Mother sang?

Reply

28 Simon May 1, 2011 at 5:42 pm

The game was played last Sunday, in the Devil’s own backyard
With Jesus playing quarterback, and Moses playing guard.
The angels in the grandstand, gave out a mighty yell
As Jesus scored a touchdown, against the boys from hell.

Go with Christ! Go with Christ!
Rock ‘em, Sock ‘em, Jesus block ‘em!
Go, Christ, Go!!!

We learned it at church camp in the ’60s
;-D

Reply

29 Susan Tiner May 1, 2011 at 6:55 pm

Cool!

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Previous post:

Next post: